Veracity of scientists’ opinion doubted
- posted Jan 21, 2014 at 4:00 PM
Re: Starfish on the decline (News, Jan. 17)
Paula Romagosa is a marine biologist and curator of Sidney’s Shaw Ocean Discovery Centre, a commercial enterprise with no governmental duty of accountability to taxpayers, so her opinion as to what is causing the ‘mysterious mass starfish deaths along the Pacific coastline’ may be interesting, but it is simply one scientist’s opinion.
According to staff writers Peter Rusland and Kyle Wells, ‘Romagosa doubted the starfish crisis was sparked by Pacific radiation from the meltdown of Japan’s Fukushima nuclear plant.’
I am not scientific but I am a trained historian (BA, University of San Francisco), and it seems highly unlikely that this alarming ‘starfish wasting syndrome’ is not being caused by a toxic brew of Fukushima radiation and the constant aerial chem spraying of aluminum, barium and strontium nanoparticulates – called ‘geo-engineering’ or ‘solar radiation management’ producing global dimming – which has been easily visible from our Rockland balcony for a number of years.
I look forward to seeing how reporters Rusland and Wells follow this very important story in the coming months, and hope that government scientists in all jurisdictions will be held accountable by their diligence.
Pacific coast starfish dying in record numbers
- by Staff Writer – Victoria News
- posted Jan 3, 2014 at 11:00 AM— updated Jan 3, 2014 at 3:22 PM
Mysterious mass starfish deaths along the Pacific coastline have marine biologists scratching their heads and scrambling to find a cause.
They’re also worried about how seastar wasting syndrome will affect ecosystems spanning Alaska to California, including those in the Greater Victoria area.
“We’ve seen it all along the Saanich Inlet, we’ve seen it around the Gulf Islands, it started in Howe Sound,” said marine biologist Paula Romagosa, curator of Sidney’s Shaw Ocean Discovery Centre.
“It’s quite serious. Nothing like this has been seen before, not to this extent.”
Just what it is that’s wiping out about 30 per cent of the coast’s observable starfish is still unknown.
“I’m quite scared, to be honest. We can’t figure out what it is, so there’s no way to control it — or know if it’ll affect our food sources like fish.”
Affected populations including sunflower, sun, basket, leather, pink, common purple, vermillion, and blood stars are dying.
“We believe its some sort of virus,” Romagosa said, “but we haven’t been able to prove it yet.”
Samples have been shipped to Cornell University, UBC, UVic, and California universities.
Divers started noticing melting and dissolving seastars in September in Howe Sound.
“It could be nature taking its course from overpopulation — or something we humans have done,” she said.
Romagosa doubts the starfish crisis was sparked by Pacific radiation from the meltdown of Japan’s Fukushima nuclear plant. She said the wasting-syndrome deaths look more like a viral infection – perhaps resembling the human ebola virus – affecting adult seastars.
“Some get bald spots, and get really skinny, and start to disintegrate. With others, their guts start coming through the pores in their skin. It’s a horrible sight to see; it’s terrifying. Their legs fall off and start walking away from the body.”
It’s tough to tell if seastars are in pain, she said.
“They don’t have a brain, but do have a nervous system so they do have pain receptors, but we’ve seen no signs of distress from the ones in the aquarium. They go about their normal activities until they just fall apart.”
Starfish also play vital roles in the food chain. “Most seastars are top predators so this will affect everything in the food chain below them. All populations that depend on the seastars as a control system will start going unchecked.”
Evidence of the seastar ailment can be sent to email@example.com or firstname.lastname@example.org.
-Reporting by Peter Rusland and Kyle Wells